Health newspaper: " doctor on punishment " For whom is the doctor shouldering the fault

Health newspaper: " doctor on punishment " For whom is the doctor shouldering the fault
Wu Shuai ( Doctor) Any unit and individual and mental hygiene medical organization collude, there is no spiritual disease personnel to hand over the institute and make a diagnosis and give treatment, and cause life, property loss,etc. serious consequence and shoulder the punishment responsibility. Recently, Municipal Standing Committee of the National People's Congress of Shenzhen reviewed <>,This regulation is expected to issue at the end of the year. This means, " psychosis " Causing the serious consequence, doctors should shoulder the punishment responsibility. As to this, the expert thinks, " difficult that this is put to the proof, but a kind of deterrence to individual prone to this. (" Beijing Times " of June 28) What is the greatest difference mental hygiene legislate? An expert who has participated in and drafted many times has provided the answer: Doctor and the public, patient, law circle personage of psychiatric department,etc. are on the issue that mental patient accepts for medical treatment by force, difference is enormous. Once " law of mental hygiene " authorizes the doctor to accept for medical treatment by force directly, a lot of people will worry, the doctor will abuse power, cause those " psychosis " The case takes place. As regards this angle, " the doctor will shoulder the punishment responsibility possibly " Perhaps coming because of this. A media understands it into such an absolutely horrified title - -<>. In any case, to the doctor of psychiatric department even for whole doctor's colony, this may be a terrible news. Undeniable, really have such a black sheep in doctor's colony. They have lost basic job quality, under the enticement of money or power, psychosis that identified as normal people, and according to the leaders' " decree " ,The innocent but pitiful person these " Lock up " In the insane asylum, give their medicine to use the calm type of spirit, destroy their spiritual will, have bodies. But the problem lies in, the proportion that such a doctor takes is extremely low, most doctors are faithful in one's own speciality, they have stood the medical education for many years, should be clear, the medical means is used for rescuing people but not victimizing. But why did some people choose to do like this? This is probably their helplessness and shame. Because it is hospital administrator that is bribed, the doctors are only the role coerced, there can only be non- black namely white choices, either obey, or go away. To be objective, a doctor, is bribed, injure patients by one's own treating right, going to destroy their body mercilessly has life. So cold-blooded a doctor, actually is few. Actually this was in the crime. In the medical field, if a doctor misdiagnoses, let the patient cause the serious consequence, they will possibly pay the cost painful enough, for example be revoked the qualification of practising medicine. If the patient has no disease, what but the doctor gave has used prescription type medicines, that means suspected of being involved in the crime of hurting one's feeling on purposing, will be investigated by the criminal law. A lot of medias have reported the similar case many times. But now, this is extremely emphasized, the doctor will misdiagnose and will be tortured the responsibility possibly. In order to console the doctors' face-off psychology slowly, legislators have set up the prerequisite - -" cause the serious consequence " . But so tight and severe a law, very few several words, the realistic influence that probably emerges to the doctors greatly. In accepting the mental patient for medical treatment thing, they will probably become more conservative. Does someone say, guard it a little, a little more prudent, is not this a good thing? Of course not. Because medical dispute emerge in an endless stream, doctors and patients contradictory like tube of powder, because some medical accident light perhaps at any time. At accepting the intersection of mental patient and the thing for medical treatment, for get into trouble little, most the intersection of doctor and attitude on very much " conservative " actually . Now, here " with a murderous look on one's face " like this Awing rod leave,can go backwards every one more at pieces of conservative direction doctors at this. Because, if make a mistake carelessly, may know and face the calamity of prison, will is there any than more terrific this thing? If meet those and does not think the patient with one's own disease, there are the relatives not understanding medical treatment, the doctors, there is one best choice, give up one's own position to judge with the speciality, these " Normal " Patient again flow into society. After all, this kind of mistaken diagnosis has no responsibility. Recently, a medical expert has proposed such a warning: "Incident on it injure while having illness coming on being innocent common people mental patient,than ' have much more more incident psychosis '. " He thinks, our country has 16 million " the real one " Heavy mental patient, among them there is " dangerous behavior " of causing trouble etc. of causing trouble clearly Patient account for 10%. This means, if the doctor of psychiatric department gives up one's own professional opinion, probably mean, a lot of patients needing to treat in fact can not get and treat in time, and then cause condition worsening and spiritual deformity, and a lot of avoidable danger happens. For example, the mental patient causes trouble and hurts one's feeling, endanger the social public security. The report " Psychosis" In the case, main one in that local officer take advantage of, link steady until by, coerce the medical organization of psychosis to make " The accomplice " ,Retaliate against and attack those innocent persons who appeal for help. Here, the power of the doctor of psychiatric department is not too big, but too small. The hospital leader can not refuse the requirement overstepping one's bounds for power, the doctors are unable to adhere to one's own professional opinion, they have just become unwilling under coercing " The accomplice " ,This's vital part. Now, under such a regulation, but the doctor coerced should receive the same punishing severely, even replace them, the person who attract people's attention paying close attention to as the public opinion, is this fair? According to own characteristic of medical treatment, it is difficult to avoid to misdiagnose, the even more sophisticated doctor can not accomplish the 100% perfection. They very difficult to estimate, receive in advance, which medical accident will one's own mistaken diagnosis will bring to patient. Though the risk misdiagnosed is ubiquitous, the doctors' authoritativeness and professional lines still need to get enough protection, should encourage them to adhere to one's own professional judgement in law. It is terrible that it is misdiagnosed but not frightened, pinion the doctor's trick artificially. Even if in the country where those laws and regulations are relatively complete, doctors can not misdiagnose and will be put into the prison soon either.

|