Debate fiercely the focal point as second instances in five questions

Debate fiercely the focal point as second instances in five questions
Staff reporter Wang Dan In news December of 2005 of background, Wang JianGuo's wife Xiong Zhuo was that (the worker of BJ Univ Hospital) In the first hospital of Peking University ' Abbreviated as BJ Univ Hospital) Accept the operation of dept. of orthopedics. On January 31, 2006, BJ Univ Hospital announced Xiong Zhuo was in order to because postoperative complication and pulmonary embolism happened, died after all rescue measures proved ineffectual. In October of 2007, Wang JianGuo prosecutes BJ Univ Hospital, thinks BJ Univ Hospital practises medicine illegally. July 1 of 2009, the judgement of Beijing No 1 Intermediate People's Court will be asserted, the damage consequence that is the death that the medical fault that BJ Univ Hospital exists causes Xiong Zhuo. After adjudiacating in the first instance, both sides refuse to obey, lodge a appeal. February 1, the intersection of Peking University and first hospital " illegality practise medicine " The second instance of the causing patient death case opens a court session in The Beijing Higher People�� s Court again. Yesterday, reporters knew while interviewing Zheng Xue Qian, attorney of BJ Univ Hospital, " whether 3 doctors in charge practise medicine for illegality " , " the operation is discussed before carrying on the skill " , " whether the patient dies from the heart, liver and breaks " Wait for 5 questions, it is still fierce focal points argued of plaintiff, defendant both sides. Open a court session this time, the court has not pronounced in court. Are 3 doctors that the illegal practice of medicine it is introduced, in this court's trial, " 3 doctors practise medicine illegally " Key for evidence,if you can't come from Wang Beijing Health Inspection, give letter in reply at JianGuo. The letter in reply claims, while recording from the clinical case history that is transferred, have not found the doctors of higher authorities to practising the signature that had been born in waiting for someone and guiding lofty and steeply, this has violated relevant regulation of Ministry of Public Health. Because the prescroption of over 2 years, Beijing Health Inspection has not implemented administrative penalty to this, but assigned " opinion book of sanitary control " to BJ Univ Hospital. But Zheng XueQian shows, the school has never received this opinion book. Zheng XueQian claims, Beijing Health Inspection has not placed on file and surveyed incident formally, that affix is not the official seal of Beijing Municipal Health Bureau. So, this letter in reply does not have legal effect. Meanwhile, because Beijing Health Inspection has not carried on further investigation on incident, the authenticity of the content of the letter in reply is worth weighing too. "In fact, by the end of 2006, 3 doctors already got doctor's operation credentials. " In addition XueQian Zheng say the intersection of plaintiff and the intersection of illegal practice of medicine and for BJ Univ Hospital subject of prosecution this, and BJ Univ Hospital has license of practising medicine as the national tertiary first rate hospital. So, it is untenable to prosecute the reason why BJ Univ Hospital requires compensation. When the accident happened, participate in two doctors that treat as the graduate, professional doctor of clinical medicine, have doctor's operation credentials, and another doctor has already passed medical practitioner's qualification test. Whether the patient dies of the liver to break to it is introduced, in the court, get heart breaking, liver of patient's death department out of and break the view caused to the plaintiff, Zheng XueQian says, after patient's death, doctors from cardiovascular disease hospital outside the mound of the Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences have already taken out the embolus from Xiong Zhuo for the lung, therefore prove the thrombus exists truly. And it is a rescue means implemented to press outside the heart after the patient breathes and stops with heart, usually press time as 0.5 hours - an hour. In order that the bear is tall and erect it is in more than 7 hours rescuing, press time for over 3 hours outside the heart, the rib appears fracture, liver break to rescue time to too cause long. In the court's trial, the school has hoped to demonstrate that rescues the method in court with the plastic dummy, in order to prove, press heart, need, exert oneself, exert oneself, may cause the intersection of rib and fracture. The judge has not allowed the requirement of the school after consideration. The one that it is reported, plaintiff attorney Fang claimed, the patient has illness coming on is as soon as possible, ones that participated in being rescued are curing and studying students and interns of universities and colleges. So, rescue and does not wait for the situation in time. The school patient to rush towards, it is an attending physician whose surname is Liu of dept. of orthopedics of BJ Univ Hospital (originally known as that it is around patient to rush towards, as soon as possible s: Liu XianYi) . Whether need to do the malpractice to appraise from first instance of 2009 to the present, plaintiff king Fang founds the state and disagrees with appraising the malpractice all the time. For this reason, on the day of court's trial, the school proposes, seeing that the details of the case is great, and concern the image of the hospital, hope outside the please breathe, emergency call, chest, dept. of orthopedics relevant speciality expert appraise the malpractice, behavior of appraising the hospital and making a diagnosis fairly, justly. The school points out, the purpose of coroner's clinical appraisal is to appraise the corpse, in order to confirm wounded or disabled grade and death reason, can not be with the picture equal sign of clinical appraisal. In addition, Zheng XueQian proposes on the law court, Wang JianGuo's agent Zhuo XiaoQin is the worker of China University of Political Science Law, and the one that examined the corpse in first instance is all China University of Political Science Law judicial expertise centre, the plaintiff is square and the appraisal organization has interests relations. Meanwhile, the doctor participating in appraising transfers from the medical college of Tongji University of Central China University of Science and Technology, mother that and Xiong Zhuo is is a professor of medical college of Tongji University, has a interests relation between them, so does not approve of a qualification here. According to media, Wang JianGuo says, mother that Xiong Zhuo is is a professor of Peking Union Medical College Hospital of Wuhan before retiring, it is not a professor of medical college of Tongji University. Moreover she is advanced in years, may not appraise the result from side to side. Whether Xiong Zhuo is serious in first instance or not when being in order to be admitted to hospital, Xiong Zhuo becomes the focal point argued too for the health status when admitted to hospital. On the day of court's trial, BJ Univ Hospital has invited the new witness to testify. 2 of philtrum for 3 cards is and Xiong Zhuo is researcher and doctor of the same laboratory, two uniform people they with wheelchair Zhuo Xiong until the intersection of scientific research and floor shift the intersection of BJ Univ Hospital and the intersection of in-patient dept. and 2 wards onto from BJ Univ Hospital at that time. Meanwhile, met a doctor of BJ Univ Hospital that examined at that time and appeared in court to verify this statement too. According to media's report, Wang JianGuo on plaintiff's mat questions the new witness after getting the judge's permission, remember precise year when the incident happens, such details as the room belonged to in place and wheelchair of the wheelchair borrowed was furnished at that time. Not when it can not remembered clearly that the witness says, Wang JianGuo rebuke angrily, is all lying. "To enclosing the understanding of deep phlebothrombosis of period of surgery insufficiently, the defect of the respect that exist and monitor, prevent and treat,etc., fail to find the forming of the deep intravenous thrombus in early days, have not taken the effective precautionary measures " Wait, is considered to cause Xiong Zhuo to be the main causes of death for a time. But school say until history record, have " the 3 years such as gastric ulcer " clearly previously in the case history Zhuo Xiong ,And the taboo that the anticoagulatory medicine employs that gastric ulcer is. Plaintiff king Fang founded the state to deny Xiong Zhuo is in order to have medical history of ulcer. And the evidence which the school provides in court shows, after first instance, Wang JianGuo has expressed Xiong Zhuo on its blog in order to suffer from ulcer clearly. To this evidence, Wang JianGuo has not denied in court. Case history distort in the first instance, plaintiff side sign for discuss the fact in front of the skill denying with " discuss, record single in front of the skill" Existence. More claim at the same time,at admitted to hospital bear tall and erect for condition last backbone slip for a time, diagnose that switches over to a backbone while being postoperative? Does ��'s news �� fetch T fierce sauce Bi Gua Zou Mou ���֮� to print? Zheng XueQian shows, according to Ministry of Public Health's request, discusses before operation that only needed to record people's signature, not needing the chief of the office of the department to sign, it does not represent that discuss not to go on before the skill that there is not the chief of the office of the department to sign. In addition, the opinion of the operation of the chief of the office of the department has already reflected in the case history before this is recorded. Diagnose and admitted to hospital, diagnose, accord with while being postoperative, only come from the X-ray slice and check to judgement, patient of condition outside the body admitted to hospital, and according to the situation finding in the skill, the patient is two degrees of backbone slip in fact. During the course of stating finally, Wang JianGuo says that can be mediated. Zheng XueQian shows, the hospital agrees to mediate too. Consider Xiong Zhuo was once a worker of BJ Univ Hospital, the hospital could offer certain compensation, but the prerequisite is to need to find out the fact.

|