Why does he become the vegetable A malpractice is endless to chase the responsibility way

Why does he become the vegetable A malpractice is endless to chase the responsibility way
The intersection of intern and the intersection of leaf and the intersection of metal bridge and core, staff reporter of Ting, Li brief 31 -year-old Dong Lin wave on to lie a solid year at sick bed this year. 3 years ago, he was cured by mistake into a vegetable by the doctor. The Dong 's got into a difficult position from then on. The wife divorces him, leave the young daughter. These more than 1000 day and night, Dong's parents went through, not only take care of the hardships of son's granddaughter, what is difficulty, malpractice charged are appraised is odd, the claim lawsuit one is long During that time, father Dong charges to the public security organ: The doctor in charge deals with criminal liability. But the real case told him in the past: It is very difficult to be investigated criminal liability to cause the doctor of the malpractice, is even investigated, also often the reprieve of judging. "Dad, turn better quickly "Two good chess Dong of half year old call. The intersection of father and forest Dong of her become the vegetable before the 3 years such as wave, lie at the sick bed of CPLA 171 Hospital now, eyes are closed, does not move at all. July of 2008, " first class second grade " that Dong LinBo's experience is identified as Chinese Medical Association once Malpractice. The intersection of forest and wave Dong become behind the vegetable, wife divorce him, leave he become daughter of two year old more than that born just after the vegetable. Dong ShuiJin, 56 -year-old father of he, retires ahead of time, attends to the son in shifts together with spouse, look after the granddaughter. The more helpless one is a long lawsuit: The tertiary medical association has made the completely different technological testimonial of malpractice, engage in behind the lawsuit of the past two years, Dong obtain more than 600,000 of compensation finally. Dong ShuiJin is unable to accept this fact, he thinks he should investigate the responsibility of the doctor in charge, then, from March of this year, he begins to put forward to departments such as the public security bureau of mouth county of lake of Jiangxi Province,etc. and charge, demand to investigate these doctors' criminal liability. From " severe low potassium disease " To " vegetable " At dusk on July 18, 2008, it is uncomfortable that Dong LinBo says to father. About 30 past 20, ShuiJin Dong accompany son come, go to a doctor from the intersection of house and closer the intersection of lake and the intersection of mouth and the intersection of county and institute of traditional Chinese medicine. The court verdict later on reveals, the diagnosis conclusion that the institute of traditional Chinese medicine of mouth county of lake provides is, Dong LinBo presents periodic paralysis and severe low potassium disease symptom, the institute of traditional Chinese medicine of mouth county of lake takes and reexamines the electrolyte, intravenous to mend potassium etc. to treat the measure. Will it be will it be 30 zero hour July 19, Dong LinBo condition worsen, appear uncomfortable in chest " angry to force " Wait for symptom, the institute of traditional Chinese medicine of mouth county of lake adopts treatment means treatments such as oxygen intake, strong heart,etc.. Dong ShuiJin says, at about 3 o'clock, Dong LinBo enters the sleep state. In the morning of the 19th, Dong ShuiJin leaves the hospital. When he leaves, sees the son as if has slept soundly generally and it is very even to breathe. He remembers doctor Liu Zheng said, " guaranteed your son was free, I was responsible for having the thing " at that time ,Let him rest assured. However, at about 30 past 8, he receives the wife's telephone in the company, says the son will die soon, he rushes for the hospital in a hurry. Reach hospital he know about 30 past 8, the intersection of forest and wave Dong breathe the heartbeat and park the state suddenly just, the institute of traditional Chinese medicine of mouth county of lake carries on the heart and lungs and recovers and meets an urgent need to rescue immediately, subsequently, Dong LinBo has resumed the heartbeat and breathed. The same day, Jiujiang the intersection of city and first doctor of the People's Hospital hold a consultation to the intersection of forest and wave Dong, feel serious, propose transferring from one hospital to another. At 35 past 13 on the same day, Jiujiang city first the People's Hospital sends the emergency tender and connects to transfer to Dong LinBo, transfer from one hospital to another, already clouded in mind LinBo Dong, why shout he respond. As to this, Jiujiang the intersection of city and first the People's Hospital while connecting and transferring to, carry on the intersection of nose and the intersection of conduit and oxygen intake to the intersection of forest and wave Dong. At about 20 past 14, Dong LinBo is sent to the People's Hospital ICU ward of Jiujiang city first, at this moment, LinBo Dong appear heartbeat breathe symptom that park suddenly again, doctor take outside the chest pressing immediately and the intersection of trachea and intubate, machinery keep in touch with etc. meet an urgent need and rescue the measure. Though the intersection of forest and wave Dong resume the normal heartbeat after 6 minutes, remain unconscious. On October 14, 2008, Dong LinBo will leave hospital from Jiujiang city first the People's Hospital. On February 18 of 2009, Dong LinBo is sent to CPLA 171 Hospital and received treatment, so far, have been in " vegetables " all the time State. "The intersection of forest and the intersection of wave and mouth Dong can't take, can only take food with the stomach tube. " Dong ShuiJin says, " we return so as to break the food boiled with the thick liquid pressing machine, and then use the syringe to get to Kuan-tzu. Feed for six or seven times each day. " Dong LinBo's defecation and urination can't be paid by oneself, moreover, like all " vegetables " The same, need two old men and turn over and carry manually once every two hours, in order to prevent the long bedsore. Telling the son's current situation, Dong ShuiJin feels sad in a period of time: "Unless he is either feel at all, joke as him,mouth of him can piece, smiling in picture. Complaining about him, he will shed tears too. " The tertiary malpractice determines that fights as the amateur personage each other, Dong ShuiJin does not understand either why turn into like this at the beginning. But he knows, a person frolicking happily is in hospital, becomes clouded in mind overnight, the hospital will certainly hardly absolve oneself of the blame. So, on May 12 of 2009, he will litigate to market Xun open district people's court of Jiujiang as Dong LinBo's legal representative, demand to investigate the malpractice responsibility of institute of traditional Chinese medicine of the lake mouth county and Jiujiang city first the People's Hospital. According to the relevant provision of " medical crash handling regulations ", " need to carry on technical appraisement of the malpractice, both parties trust the medical association responsible for technical appraisement work of the malpractice to organize appraising together " . Entrust by Xun open district people's court, Jiujiang the intersection of city and medical association make a diagnosis to Dong LinBo the course has been appraised. On June 23 of 2009, the medical association of Jiujiang will make " technological testimonial of the malpractice ", will determine the result is: "Though the institute of traditional Chinese medicine of mouth county of lake has a defect in the course of dealing with this patient, but the patient's end turn, return to ' Point transformation and development) of the condition ,Result from the reason that serious, there is no causality with the treatment of the hospital, do not form the malpractice " . Think " has not violated the medical routine, the measure is apt in Jiujiang city first the People's Hospital at the same time Do not form the malpractice " . Dong ShuiJin, to determining the result does not agree with, puts forward and appraises the application again. Trusted by Xun open district people's court, the medical association of Jiangxi Province makes the new malpractice technical appraisement on November 3 of 2009, the expert thinks the institute of traditional Chinese medicine of mouth county of lake has faults, includes knowing to condition and consequence seriously insufficiently, notify critically ill in time, carry on the intersection of heart and electricity, breathe, guard in time, strong heart that select for use, mend alkali, treat according to enough, etc. Jiujiang city first the People's Hospital even stores in transshipping and supports the measure to pay little attention to etc. in the course insufficiently in breathing. Therefore, the medical association of Jiangxi Province asserts, this case is a first class second grade malpractice, the hospital undertakes secondary responsibility (the institute of traditional Chinese medicine of mouth county of lake undertakes 80% of secondary responsibility among them, Jiujiang city first the People's Hospital bears 20%) of secondary responsibility . With because of conclusion this The conclusion of the medical association of Jiujiang is completely different, the plaintifves both say with the defendant to refuse to obey, put forward the requirement Chinese Medical Association to appraise again. In this way, does open district people's court trust Chinese medicine Xun through the higher people's court of Jiangxi Province? �� Jiao ��'s bits � ? On March 23, 2010, Chinese Medical Association will make the testimonial, will assert too this accident is a first class second grade malpractice. Different from expert's conclusion of the medical association of Jiangxi Province, Chinese Medical Association thinks two hospitals should bear the ultimate liability of the accident. In view of the above, Xun open the intersection of city and people's court assign court verdict on will it be August 23 2010, judgement LinBo Dong obtain medical fee, delay work fee, the intersection of person who accompany and attend to the fee and expense total value amount to 642432.01 yuan, among them it is 513945.61 yuan that the institute of traditional Chinese medicine of mouth county of lake bears 80%, Jiujiang city first the People's Hospital bears 128486.40 yuan. Because this incident is a malpractice, it is for two defendants' account to appraise the fee. Lawsuit for 15 months since the end of and the assigning of court verdict have. Dong ShuiJin and defendant the People's Hospital of Jiujiang city first both put forward appeal to the intermediate people's court of Jiujiang. "In fact in this accident, we are comparative wrong. " Person in charge of family of medical matters of Jiujiang city first the People's Hospital Yuan XiangYang says to China Youth News reporter: "The patient family members made a noise in the institute of traditional Chinese medicine of mouth county of lake terribly at that time, the county government of mouth of lake set out from linking the steady angle, finding our leadership of the hospital hopes to meet patients. The car-mounted breathing machine of the hospital at that time, according to the routine, we would not go to meet the patient voluntarily, the patient was generally sent in. In fact we have done the good thing, but there is no good result. " Jiujiang city first the People's Hospital still thinks: "Chinese Medical Association does not understand the hospital medical facilities at the basic level are disposed low, the medical condition is bad, the expert's conclusion has broken away from local reality " ,So ask the hospital to only bear 60% of the responsibility. But the intersection of water and money Dong think damage of LinBo Dong totally arise from malpractice of the hospital, the hospital should bear 90% of the responsibility. Meanwhile, he is right to attend to the fee, have objections too by the compensation number of raising living cost of people, deformity apparatus fee,etc.. On November 30, 2010, the intermediate people's court of Jiujiang will make " rejects the appeal and upholds decision " Final judgement. Two funds which hospitals compensated have already been put in place at present. Relatives demand to investigate the punishment responsibility of the doctor in charge just the same as a lot of medical disputes, in incident this, distort case history, become the intersection of ink and King Dong to chase the important direction of the responsibility later stage. "I son have first overbearing at all, hospital case history make the fake, make up the intersection of I and son have first overbearing. " Dong ShuiJin says. Can be seen from the temporary doctor's order form copy which Dong ShuiJin offered, from the July 19 to October 14, 2008, the hospital has done 8 first overbearing inspections for Dong LinBo. Leave hospital to reveal yes three items are not up to standard on the record. But on February 21 of 2009, in the survey report of CPLA 171 Hospital, but reveal the above-mentioned three items are qualified, moreover, it is qualified to check and all show 4 times hereafter. Because basically can not cure in first overbearing 3 months, Dong ShuiJin suspects Jiujiang city first the People's Hospital may have case histories to make the fake. But the expert's conclusion of Chinese Medical Association thinks, the hospital first is overbearing to diagnose that is established, the probation report thinks Dong LinBo " The consequence at present " Overbearing with first to have nothing to do. Person in charge of subject of medical matters of Jiujiang city first the People's Hospital Yuan XiangYang says while giving an interview: "First overbearing diagnosis must exist, and there is a conclusion on the testimonial of Chinese Medical Association. First is overbearing to have nothing to do with the patient's damage consequence, it is unnecessary for us to make up such a disease, this is nonsensical. " Not having first overbearing situation at present as to the patient, Yuan XiangYang says: "Some things on medical science are unable to be explained, we can not say clearly either. But I can say responsibly the patient really had overbearing first at that time. We are hospital of a the first, second and third, the medical examination is an extraordinary norm. " Besides suspecting to distort the case history, Dong JinShui also puts forward to local public security organ and charges, demand to investigate the institute of traditional Chinese medicine of mouth county of lake, responsibility of the relevant medical worker of the People's Hospital of Jiujiang city first, "the misfortune of our family, it was medical workers of two hospitals that cause, must investigate their criminal liability. " Dong ShuiJin thinks there are direct relations in the malfeasance of Dong LinBo's ischemic oxygen deficiency encephalopathy and doctor, Dong LinBo ties severe low potassium disease when admitted to hospital, the expert's conclusion of Chinese Medical Association thinks hypokalemia disease is diagnosed and dealt with uncomplicatedly, " if the hospital takes the correct and effective measure of treatment and cure, most patients can avoid breathing the heartbeat to suspend the situation and take place suddenly " . Will it be June 22 2011 year, lake the intersection of mouth and the intersection of county and public security bureau place on file formally, to suspected of being involved in the intersection of malpractice and meeting, examining the intersection of doctor and policy Liu, launching investigating guilty. Dong ShuiJin tells reporters, in May of this year, classmate Liu AiYuan of doctor Liu Zheng's brother-in-law, nephew and Dong ShuiJin comes to the hospital, " quote 100,000 yuan, want me to inform Liu Zheng " . July 21, Zheng Liu trust Liu like yuan send a telegram to the intersection of ink and King Dong, " added by 20,000 yuan on the original basis again, demand to solve privately " . As to this, reporter phone, solve to policy Liu, but mobile phone of him in " incoming telegram remind " State. Reporter send a telegram to Liu love yuan, Liu verify the intersection of water and statement of King Dong, AiYuan Liu say: "I remember both sides meet in May, Liu Zheng's brother-in-law agrees to take out 80,000 yuan to solve privately. " Recently, China Youth News reporter telegraph the intersection of lake and the intersection of mouth and the intersection of county and public security bureau, responsible for captain Wang of case this, he says, this case is in investigation at present, does not have too much progress, have not been transferred in the procuratorate yet. Dong ShuiJin tells China Youth News reporter, in order to cure the disease for the son, their family has sold the house too. At the beginning of of 2011, the daughter-in-law went through formalities of divorcing with the son too, he considers daughters-in-law are young, for not influencing daughter-in-law's future life, agree the daughter-in-law removes the marriage with the son. Guardian, as Dong LinBo of his pushes the impression of the hand in the divorce agreement. According to the agreement, two years old and more than Dong JiaQies raise grandparents. Dong ShuiJin says, son's present condition is more steady. " whether could resume, the doctor says that can only look forward to the emergence of the miracle " . Though has already many in the past 3 years, Dong ShuiJin still insists on chasing the responsibility and safeguarding the rights, "the malpractice has happened in the hospital, it is impossible to compensate some money let it be! "

|