From " heavy metal cigarette " See expert's sophistry

From " heavy metal cigarette " See expert's sophistry
The international tobacco controls the policy to assess the project (ITC) The scientific research report that the organization announces reveals, 13 domestic cigarette brand products in China detect and contain the heavy metal, content with Canada its produce cigarette, compare, most superb to produce more than triple, respond to relevant enterprise, national the intersection of tobacco and general bureau this (October 10 " Yangzi Evening ") . Relevant enterprises, and the response of relevant officer of State Tobacco Monopoly Bureau, " characteristic " as before , " classics " : First say: " too high raw materials for production (tobacco leaf) that point in the report Heavy metal too high, this have something to do with the intersection of tobacco leaf and climatic condition of person who produce, but this the intersection of group and what can control. " It is obviously the diction shirking responsibility not sophisticated, enterprises can not control the content of heavy metal of raw materials truly, and in every case have commercial personal integrity, would like to bearing responsibility publically safely, totally have the ability to examine raw materials quality, and the one that choose the better raw materials for production; Moreover say: "Though our country has not issued the heavy metal market access standard to the whole cigarette yet, but the standard have China, have in the world, Canadian researcher stop production cigarette as the object of reference even with national smoke "Resort to sophistry. On concrete links, the question, should only pay close attention to, respond, it can only be whether the content of heavy metal high reaches the intensity of endangering the public security. Who will care with another kind of cigarette, even is the cigarette that has already stopped production compared with? Three are called: "Mention most superb to produce more than triple in the report, that is to say it is all 13 the intersection of cigarette and content of heavy metal that higher than triple. " Have obviously held a memorial ceremony for out again " The finger theory " --Even if 9 fingers are all black, it is not black not to also have a finger! Often say while argueing: " by the look of angle of so-and-so's position and so-and-so " ,Namely the position is different from angle, direct against the same thing, will draw different conclusions. In the thing of this piece specifically, it is public vital interests, public and safe on the highest position and angle, must entertain to relevant result, an attitude that tolerates of the state, the persistent one is that public interests are maximized, the persistent one is to do all things better, accomplish best; On the contrary, on power interests, special interests position and angle, it is not public interests that are maximized, but the control ability of power, special interests are maximized, the persistent one is to extend power and special interests, for this reason, certain to close the eyes fine to look for insufficient, close eyes, think public interests, public and safe, and end time of magnifying glasses look for score, for extend, insist power and whom special interests does not waver reasonable to plead while being getting proper. We can detect on a lot of concrete problems from the question on door of this cigarette heavy metal, the so-called " major personages" , " expert's voice " Where does the sharp conflict with public opinion comes from, only lie in the position between each other is different from angle. In fact, a feeling is that someone's institute is, the question of right for use in anyone's place. This's weigh, judge the most crucial index of the merits and demerits. One kind of meanings was considered, was known as " brick family " from then on Expert,getting be more abstandard in fact either, quibble just. Unfortunately, they have not realized, it is not the topic that what oneself participated in is public, but not the game argued. Only it can realize public interests are maximized, citizen's right is maximized like this. Otherwise the intersection of feeling and department for the people, right civil, but persistent on power, special the intersection of interests and maximization of itself, having not merely violated modern society's most basic ethics morality and justice, must not be held by the public, will inevitablely also deceive and take care of public interests, cause and indulge the long-standing abuse that the society runs on each link and grow thickly, hinder social progress. (Xu Bin in Hubei)

|