Plagiarize the investigation result of the incident and is queried in dean's thesis of Chinese medicine of Yunnan

Plagiarize the investigation result of the incident and is queried in dean's thesis of Chinese medicine of Yunnan
On April 19, in the biggest network community of Yunnan - -Yunnan net " The green workshop of gold " Tops 150,000, over 1400 net friends to leave a message in clicking rate of a model in the forum, hereto establish the regional forum in less than 1 year and, it has already been astronomical figure. Meanwhile, the clicking rate of this card on native forums such as Yunnan inforport, elder brother's Yunnan E,etc. rises violently all the way too, nearly all to leave a message " Lean to one side " The ground is reproached and queried. All these are because of February 13 one is called the model that " dean Li QingSheng copies others' thesis so to register the department of Chinese medicine ". Though the model has already been sent for two months, " send forces to suppress " on net that is originally already put down gradually , but because the news briefing on April 10 characterizes this as " excessively quotes " ,Make this incident pushed to the teeth of the storm of the network public opinion again. The net friend sends the card: <> Card this earlier than, appear in the intersection of China and academic forum February 11 most, " whether see big professor how about copy article ". Author " apologist " Call it due to working reasons, while reading the technical literature, find Yunnan dean Li QingSheng of Chinese medicine is on 2003 third issue of " journal of college of traditional Chinese medicine of Yunnan ", publish " modern development trend and the intersection of characteristic and brief analysis of life sciences " article with call scholar that relieve, entitled as on one that 1979 deliver at the journal of Xiamen University ' The thesis of new characteristic of trying talking about modern biological scientific development>> " Bearing the surprising similarity with " . " apologist " Have also enumerated the numerous similarity of two articles, and claim in some paragraphs or even the word word is the same, " the full text has been had a look around, the same paragraph is basically up to about 3000 words " . Notify to the media, Li QingSheng's article amounts to 9500 words afterwards according to Vice President of Yunnan college of traditional Chinese medicine Zheng Jin, namely nearly 1/ 3 of the contents of this article come from the thesis that relieves. However, this card has not been paid close attention to, only a net friend leaves a message. On February 13, this card is transferred to Yunnan net " green workshop of gold " by the net friend The forum, become the focus that the net friend talks about at once, it is carried on carefully and compared that the enthusiastic net friend even found two articles, and enumerate out and duplicate some detailed positions. Meanwhile, the net friend claims with the card, find Li Qing has a problem that a draft throw to survive more. Becoming the focus of the public opinion with this card gradually, the party has made a response too. On February 16, Li QingSheng requires relevant staff members of college of traditional Chinese medicine to assist to do the relevant job well, prevent the state of affair from expanding. Later, he required it in order to organize the name to write to the media, demanded to propagandize this. This institute Party Committee with "it is report individual,should not in order to organizing name not to be responded " It is from,it is respond not to propose by it, or it is maintain by legitimate rights and interestses one's own not to resort to legal proceedings. On March 29, the working committee of the university of Yunnan Province, education department put forward the handling suggestion on this, among them require the academic committee of college of traditional Chinese medicine of Yunnan to appraise this within one week, and is in charge of appraising the work by Vice President of Yunnan college of traditional Chinese medicine Zheng Jin. On April 10, the college of traditional Chinese medicine of Yunnan holds the news briefing, determines the result is notified media of: Li QingSheng article ( Hereafter referred to as Lee gently) With relieving and publishing existing during " trying talking about the new characteristic of scientific development of the modern life " and " new characteristic of modern biological scientific development " in 1985 in 1979 separately " it is improper to excessively quote " to burn Question,and last 3 item basis of result: Li Wen is not an original thesis, it is actually a guiding survey article; Li Wen quotes gentle space for week too much, the quoting amount is too big; Wen Li list, relieve on 1985 " the modern biological new characteristic of scientific development " that publish at " the medical science and philosophy " in references, but not adopted quotation marks to list the quoted passage alone, or add footnotes after the quoted passage directly, or prove in the text. Grow 3 articles written in addition as to Li Qing and is thrown by more than one draft, this academic committee is identified as not throwing by more than one draft, but there is improper: The data that first two articles use are the same mostly, and is taken from the same experiment, in terms of research thesis, the detailed statement of the method of its experiment, experimental result can only present once, should describe and mark out the first thesis source briefly when appear for the second time, so there is improper. Investigation result: " excessively quote " But not " plagiarize " Net friends are obviously rather discontented with this handling suggestion. At one time, " excessively quote " Become the popular word on native forum. To the public query, Zheng Jin claims, for plagiarizing, no clear standards. "We have studied and consulted notice and relevant norm of Ministry of Education, have not found the statement on plagiarizing. " Zheng Jin emphasizes more than once, Li Wen is not an original thesis, but one is summarized. Zheng Jin says, the college of traditional Chinese medicine trusts Tsing-Hua University through plagiarizing the software to appraise instead, find duplicating the number of words and reaching 3017 of Li Wen and an article that relieves. "But this qualification result does not have legal effect. " Zheng enters and adds. According to national relevant regulations: It is not that the works of parts of speech of poem can't exceed 2500 words or be quoted 1/ 10 of the works to quote; Quote the work of a person or many people, the total amount quoted can't exceed 1/ 10 that I created the total amount of the works. "Theoretically, can already characterized as and plagiarized. " Lin Wen, lawyer of group of eight modest lawyers in Yunnan, says, " excessively quotes " It is not the reason of contradicting. He says at the same time, the works have already formed subject terms plagiarized, no matter the thesis or summarizing, have nothing to do with the types of the article. This qualification has not introduced the third party, but been appraised inside by the academic committee of college of traditional Chinese medicine of Yunnan. To the query of its just objectivity to the external world, Deputy Secretary of Party Committee of Yunnan college of traditional Chinese medicine Wang CuiGang says, investigate and determine, go on according to the intersection of Provincial Party committee and the intersection of university and working committee, the intersection of province and suggestion of education department, in the course of investigating and appraising, Li QingSheng avoids in the whole journey, investigation, qualification of the academic committee of the institute are independent. Zheng enters to add, not only there are personnel in schools in this committee,but also also include the not less than 5 people famous expert outside school, so should determine the result has convincingness. When students express somewhat approval this to fry burning hot, but Li QingSheng has chosen silence. This person college of traditional Chinese medicine study, work 30 over the intersection of senior statesman and magnitudes of personage of year in Yunnan already, quite prestigious in the field of teaching of Chinese medicine of Yunnan, he is that few of circles of Chinese medicine of Yunnan have already enjoyed Yunnan Province " government's special subsidy " too " good at, treat difficult and complicated cases of Chinese medicine " "Yunnan Province famous Chinese medicine " . At the beginning of incident, he once stated frankly " lesson " to the media ,Later not interview by media. It is reported, Li QingSheng is with " high standard and strict requirement of a Party member's professor, leading cadre at the internal meeting, seek truth from facts, draw the angle of the lesson " Criticize oneself Comment and make a self-criticism, and claim this has all caused the great injury to institute and individual, will hope for its influence on working in the institute to minimize. But, do the students of this school express? Large to impose, shake ��, imitate short coat, hack Suan thin 1, charge the whore � very hide? Famous students, except that a girl of nursing speciality says this may have a certain influence to his employment, other students have expressed the somewhat approval of this incident. Specialized five big students say that one are clinical: "This can't be called and plagiarized, in the university all like this now, it is improper to just quote at most. " And another student says: "Say this cause harmful effects to school, one Li celebrate one's birthday and can not change something in fact. You see the Specialist Clinic by our institute, it is not 4 o'clock every day before dawn someone line up to register as before. This thing does not matter, it is not a criminal case. " As to students' indifference, Zheng SiLi, Professor of Yunnan University, has expressed one's own worry: "It was a extremely abominable behavior that this kind was plagiarized, have not merely influenced the reputation of the school, the most serious one is to establish a model of reverse side for students. Since the teachers all plagiarize, it seems bold and more assured that that student plagiarizes. If the wind with corrupt academy is unable to wipe out in the university, people in subordinate position will follow the patterns set by their superiors, the words beginning to destroy game rules from the executor, then, the atmosphere will be worse and worse, the impact on student will be fatal too. "

|